Laura Wright 
There are some Appalachian ghost stories that were never intended to be subtle.
Old Tom is one of them.
He isn’t a pale woman glimpsed beside a cemetery road. He doesn’t appear as a shadow in the window of an abandoned house. There are no mysterious footsteps or softly whispered voices.
Old Tom is said to wander the lonely roads and lovers’ lanes of East Tennessee, looking almost human from a distance.
Get close enough, however, and the illusion disappears.
His skin is gone.
His body is skeletal and raw.
And according to the legend, his heart can still be seen beating inside his chest.
The creature is also known by a considerably more descriptive name:
Skinned Tom.
Tom Before the Ghost
The story is usually placed during the 1920s, when Prohibition had changed drinking without doing much to eliminate it.
Speakeasies, moonshine and bootlegging flourished throughout the country, and Appalachia had its own long relationship with illicit liquor.
According to the legend, Tom embraced the wilder side of the era.
He drank.
He chased women.
He enjoyed nightlife.
And he had a reputation as something of a ladies’ man.
But Tom supposedly had one firm rule.
He would never become involved with a married woman.
That rule would eventually kill him.
The Woman Who Lied
One evening, Tom met a woman who was different from the others.
The surviving version does not preserve her real name, if she ever had one. For convenience, the older article calls her Betty, and we’ll continue doing so while remembering that the name is part of the storytelling rather than documented history.
Tom fell in love with her.
Betty told him she was single.
She wasn’t.
She had a husband.
And eventually her husband discovered the affair.
Lovers’ Lane
The confrontation supposedly occurred at a local lovers’ lane.
Tom and Betty were together inside Tom’s automobile when her husband found them.
What happened next is the reason the story survived.
According to the legend, the husband attacked Betty first, stabbing her while she sat in the car. He then dragged Tom from the automobile.
But he didn’t simply kill him.
He skinned Tom alive.
Betty managed to escape and summon help.
By the time people returned, however, something was wrong.
Tom’s body was gone.
Where Did the Body Go?
This is one of the best details in the legend because it marks the point where an ordinary crime story crosses completely into folklore.
A man has supposedly been murdered in an extraordinarily brutal fashion.
Witnesses return.
And there is no corpse.
The story maintains that Betty’s husband was subsequently convicted and sent to prison while Betty survived her injuries, although she supposedly never completely recovered from what happened.
The historical problem is obvious.
A murder this grotesque, followed by a prosecution and imprisonment, should have left records.
I have not found reliable contemporary newspaper or court documentation identifying a real Tom, Betty or jealous husband corresponding to the familiar legend.
Modern retellings repeat essentially the same story. One version describes Skinned Tom specifically as an East Tennessee lovers’-lane ghost and preserves the familiar explanation that he was killed by an enraged husband after being caught with another man’s wife.
So, at least for now, Old Tom should be treated as folklore rather than a documented 1920s murder case.
That doesn’t make the story any less Appalachian.
In fact, the legend appears to have genuinely circulated in the region.
“Have You Seen the Ghost of Tom?”
The story has survived in East Tennessee oral tradition, including a little rhyme associated with Skinned Tom:
“Have you seen the ghost of Tom…”
The remainder cheerfully describes the unfortunate condition of a man without any skin.
A modern East Tennessee storyteller recalls growing up with the tale and describes it as a legend passed down for decades, particularly as a warning concerning questionable romantic behavior.
That is important.
It doesn’t establish that Tom existed.
But it does show that the story isn’t merely an isolated Internet invention.
People in East Tennessee were telling some version of Skinned Tom.
The Thing Beside the Road
According to the legend, Tom still appears around isolated places where couples park at night.
From a distance, there may be nothing obviously supernatural about him.
He appears to be a man dressed in clothing reminiscent of the period, sometimes described with his shirt hanging open.
Then he approaches.
And the closer he gets, the less human he appears.
His skin is missing.
His exposed body is sometimes described as skeletal, while other versions make him considerably more gruesome, with muscle and internal organs visible beneath what should have been skin.
Most unsettling of all is the heart.
It is still beating.
Tom has been dead for generations.
His heart apparently hasn’t noticed.
Why Does Tom Attack Women?
Here the legend becomes slightly contradictory.
Tom supposedly refused to knowingly become involved with married women. Betty deceived him. Her husband murdered him.
Yet in many versions of the story, the resurrected Tom directs his anger toward women.
Some accounts suggest that he attacks women encountered at lovers’ lanes. Others portray him more generally as a threat to couples who have gone somewhere secluded for romantic purposes.
If we try to apply logic to the ghost, his choice of victims seems rather unfair.
Tom was deceived.
Betty was attacked too.
The husband was the murderer.
Yet somehow generations of storytelling transformed Tom into the monster.
That probably tells us something about what the legend eventually became.
Old Tom stopped being the ghost of a murder victim.
He became a warning.
Don’t Go Parking After Dark
Many ghost stories perform a social function.
They tell people where not to go.
Don’t enter the abandoned house.
Don’t walk through the cemetery after midnight.
Don’t follow strange lights into the woods.
And definitely don’t take your sweetheart to an isolated road where nobody knows what you’re doing.
Old Tom fits beautifully into that tradition.
Young couples needed privacy.
Parents preferred that they didn’t have it.
Folklore provided enforcement.
You might get away with sneaking off to lovers’ lane.
But Old Tom was already there.
The legend therefore carries the unmistakable flavor of a cautionary tale concerning sex, adultery and secret relationships.
Behave yourself.
Or something without skin might come knocking on the car window.
Subtle it isn’t.
Effective?
Absolutely.
Lovers’ Lanes and American Folklore
The lovers’ lane became a remarkably fertile setting for twentieth-century American urban legends.
It offered everything a frightening story needed.
Isolation.
Darkness.
Young people doing something their parents probably wouldn’t approve of.
A parked automobile that suddenly becomes both shelter and trap.
Stories about escaped lunatics, hook-handed killers, mysterious tapping on the roof and attackers hiding outside automobiles flourished in precisely this environment.
Old Tom belongs comfortably among them.
But he carries a particularly Appalachian grotesqueness.
The punishment isn’t delivered by an escaped killer.
It comes from someone who was himself murdered at a lovers’ lane.
The crime created the monster that now guards the place.
Did Old Tom Really Exist?
At present, there isn’t enough evidence to say that he did.
The familiar story supplies almost everything a researcher would want except the details necessary to verify it.
No full name.
No reliable date.
No identified victim.
No named husband.
No court case.
No newspaper citation.
Even the location varies in retellings.
Some modern versions place the legend around Rogersville, Tennessee, while broader tellings simply identify East Tennessee.
That doesn’t mean there wasn’t some real incident behind the story.
An affair may have ended violently.
A man named Tom may have been murdered.
An old lovers’ lane may have developed a ghost story independently.
Several unrelated incidents may have gradually merged.
But the elaborate skinning, disappearing corpse and visibly beating heart belong firmly within folklore unless historical documentation eventually surfaces.
And that’s fine.
Not every ghost needs a birth certificate.
The Missing Corpse
There is still something interesting about the disappearance of Tom’s body.
Folklore often needs a reason the dead can return.
An improperly buried body is one of the oldest.
Someone murdered and buried normally has undergone the expected transition.
The funeral occurs.
The grave is closed.
The living know where the dead belong.
Tom receives none of that.
His body simply disappears.
There is no burial.
No grave.
No resting place.
The story leaves him permanently unfinished.
That may be accidental storytelling.
Or it may be exactly why Old Tom is still walking.
The Skinless Dead
There is also something unusually primal about removing the skin.
Skin marks the boundary of the body.
It separates the self from everything outside it.
Take it away and the human figure remains recognizable while becoming profoundly wrong.
That may explain why Skinned Tom is considerably more memorable than an ordinary roadside ghost.
You recognize him.
Then you realize what is missing.
The effect is made worse by the supposedly beating heart.
Tom isn’t a skeleton.
He isn’t a corpse.
Something inside him remains horribly alive.
Perhaps He Isn’t Looking for Victims
There is another way to interpret the legend.
Perhaps Old Tom isn’t roaming the roads because he hates women.
Maybe later storytellers supplied that motivation because monsters are expected to attack people.
The older idea may have been simpler.
Tom’s body disappeared.
He never received a grave.
And now he keeps returning to the place where he died.
Perhaps he isn’t hunting anyone.
Perhaps he is still looking for Betty.
Or perhaps he is simply repeating the final night of his life.
A man drives to a secluded place with a woman he loves.
Someone finds them.
Violence follows.
Then Tom is left somewhere between the living and the dead, his heart still beating beneath a body from which everything protecting it has been stripped away.
That version is less of a morality tale.
And considerably sadder.
Old Tom Is Still Out There
There is little reason to accept the familiar Skinned Tom story as literal history.
The documentation simply isn’t there.
But the legend itself belongs to East Tennessee folklore and has apparently been told in the region for decades.
And perhaps that’s where Old Tom belongs.
Not in a courthouse record.
Not beneath a cemetery marker.
But somewhere along an old Tennessee road after dark.
A couple parks where they think nobody will find them.
The engine goes quiet.
The woods settle around the car.
Then someone notices a man standing farther down the road.
He looks ordinary enough.
He starts walking toward them.
Closer.
Closer.
Something about his shirt looks strange.
Then the headlights catch his chest.
There is no skin.
And somewhere inside that ruined body, after nearly a century,
Old Tom’s heart is still beating.
About the Author
