James A. Mahoney’s is little known today, but he was a Bristol pioneer on both sides of the state line. Despite his affluence, his bizarre death sent shock waves across the nation and brought about the first questions of how effectively Veterans’ Affairs hospitals really treated their patients.
About Mahoney
Mahoney’s family originated in Greene County, Tennessee, but he spent the majority of his life in Bristol. He was the surviving son of John Mahoney, another hugely successful Bristolian. The 214 Solar Street, or “Solar Hill,” resident lived in his parents’ mansion, today known as the Gautnier-Mahoney House.
During World War I, Mahoney served in the French Ambulance Corps, where he developed his love of travel. He was educated at Emory and Henry, before he went on to Columbia University. He studied art in Paris, but eventually returned to the United States.
He didn’t marry and never had children. Mahoney was part-owner of the fledgling radio station, WCYB. Early in his career, he wrote numerous pieces for the Saturday Evening Post, Cosmopolitan, Century, and several other prestigious publications. He received the esteemed O. Henry Award several times from 1921-1923.
He owned roughly one-third of the business properties on and around State Street. His buildings included the Central Building at State and Sixth Streets, Sterling House, the Sterchi Building, the building for Rose’s Five-and-Ten-Cent Store, the bank building, as well as other State Street properties behind the family house.
He was an avid supporter of Abingdon’s Barter Theater, as well as the Jane Hammit Home for Underprivileged Children. This came to be later known as the Jane Hammit Memorial Orphanage.
Mahoney was active in the realm of Southern politics. He actively supported Senator Estes Kefauver in the 1948 Senate race. Kefauver defeated the Tennessee Democratic boss, E. H. Crump. Mahoney was worldly, traveled, and rumors persist of several homosexual relationships. A 1997 biography of composer Virgil Thompson mentioned a relationship with James Mahoney during the 1920s.
Unfortunately, none of his affluence, wealth, or success helped him on his final vacation. The 55-year-old planned to explore the Yucatan, with a stopover in New Orleans. He arrived in Louisiana on February 20, with the intention of flying on to Central America on February 22. Mardi Gras was ongoing and the city was filled with bright lights and festivities.
New Orleans
Mahoney checked into the French Quarter’s Monteleone Hotel on Sunday morning. His itinerary in New Orleans remains unknown, but nothing about this case would ever be typical. He made a strange request for an extra cot in his room, but no one witnessed a single person in his company after check-in. Mahoney didn’t make or receive a single telephone call.
Several witnesses reported a female had accompanied him when he arrived, but she left as soon as they stepped off the bus. Her identity remains unknown. Police dismissed her as a suspect, perhaps a little too soon.
Mahoney visited a photography supply store, where he spoke with clerk Martin Gattis, on the morning of February 21. He purchased a camera exposure meter, as well as an inexpensive gold ring he had engraved with, “Mother to James.” This was a bizarre request because Mahoney’s mother died two years earlier. The authorities were likewise unable to establish his whereabouts for the rest of the day.
The sequence of events continues to puzzle today. The hotel was packed with celebration attendees, the streets bustled with festivities at all hours, yet not a single person saw him return to his room.
The Shock
Mahoney called the front desk somewhere around 11 pm. He requested a wakeup call at 5:30 the next morning. His South American flight was scheduled to leave at 8:00 am.
The hotel operator called the next morning, but no one answered. At 6:15 am, she dispatched a bellboy to wake him. The bellboy discovered Mahoney’s body.
Mahoney’s body laid upside down on the bed, with his feet on the pillows and his head at the foot. Other than a sheet draped across his midsection, he was completely nude. Half of his skull was beaten in and a bloody towel remained twisted around his throat. There were no other signs of a struggle in the room. The killer apparently wiped his or her bloody hands on Mahoney’s trousers and left. The handprints were so smeared they had no identification value.
The autopsy revealed Mahoney sustained both a fatal concussion and broken neck. The coroner determined Mahoney died from his head injuries before his neck was broken. There was also no evidence of self-defense, except for a tiny cut on his right hand, which may or may not have been made during the struggle.
The authorities were stunned. The motive wasn’t robbery, even though whoever did it clearly searched Mahoney’s belongings. Mahoney’s keys, wallet, and watch were missing, but the killer ignored loose change, $1,400 in traveler’s checks, and two expensive cameras. Rumors suggested Mahoney carried $2,000 in cash, but it was never substantiated. Mahoney might’ve carried something that only had value to an associate, be it incriminating or personal, but the possibility was never pursued.
The authorities didn’t know where to start. Their investigation was at a standstill from the beginning, partly due to the tremendous number of Mardi Gras attendees. What should’ve been a countless number of witnesses became a staggering number of hindrances. Mahoney hadn’t traveled with anyone, and no one knew where he went while in New Orleans. Despite the media’s involvement, and so much publicity, Mahoney’s final days remained a mystery.
Suspects
The potential suspects were as obscure as Mahoney’s itinerary. The authorities searched for individuals such as an, “unnamed woman,” a “large man with big ears,” and a “youth in a green, striped sweater.” Since no one witnessed Mahoney in the company of anyone else, police had only rumors and supposition.
Several witnesses claimed the “large man” was Mahoney’s drinking companion Monday evening. In the first two days of the investigation, the authorities questioned over 80 people. A few days later, the number swelled to over 120.
After the authorities released information on the murder, Edwin Lewis bragged about his friendship with Mahoney in a French Quarter bar. The authorities brought him in for a series of interrogations and he was held several days. Lewis, a carpenter from Richmond, Virginia, was never witnessed in Mahoney’s company. With nothing to further corroborate his story, he was released.
The authorities developed the three rolls of film found in Mahoney’s belongings, but didn’t find any leads. They also said Mahoney had a telegram from a Bristol woman who wanted to meet him in New Orleans, and from there she would accompany him to Central America. That was also a dead end.
The witnesses who reported the young man in the sweater stated the stranger stood outside Mahoney’s room, or in the hotel, at the time of the murder. No one actually saw him enter or leave the hotel. It’s also unlikely that a murderer who had just physically beaten another man to death would loiter near the scene. Sketch artists got as many details as they could from the few people who thought they saw him and compiled a sketch.
Four days later, the authorities apprehended a man named Eugene Lewis Hoover. The Louisville native just been released from the Veterans Affairs hospital after another lengthy stay. He looked somewhat like the sketch, and his sweater kind of resembled what witnesses reported, so they brought him in. What followed became a media circus.
Sweater Boy
The infamous sweater drew almost as much attention as the crime itself. At first, the youth in the sweater was only around 16 or 17. He appeared and disappeared from the hotel and few witnesses believed they saw him at all. Eugene Lewis Hoover, 25, was a mentally imbalanced World War II Veteran. He became the focus because he had a similar sweater.
Unfortunately, Hoover suffered from “acute hysteria.” This conversion disorder makes the body manifest an individual’s anxieties through physical symptoms. The disorder triggers a variety of symptoms, such as black-outs, hysteria, aggression, abrupt physical handicaps, and even hallucinations. Hoover was just released from the VA hospital the day before the murder and returned the next.
At first, police said Mahoney had bloodstains on his clothes and bloody bruises on his hands. That notion was overshadowed by the fact that nearly a week had passed, and he’d been hospitalized the whole time. Hospital staff would have noticed bloody clothing, injuries, or any physical indications of violence.
Hoover was already delusional, and the authorities made no real effort to avoid feeding his troubled mind. Perhaps they found an easy way to close what would’ve been an otherwise impossible case.
Hoover actually requested the authorities administer truth serum. He had no recollection of Monday night through waking up Tuesday afternoon. He believed the “truth serum,” would give those memories back. According to the authorities’ documentation, the drug gave Hoover an extreme high.
Truth serum was Pentothal sodium, a barbiturate still used in lethal injections. A 1941 medical study conducted on veterans proved Pentothal sodium actually had a beneficial effect on victims of acute hysteria.
Unfortunately, the barbiturates also caused innocent people to make false confessions. While under the drug’s influence, Hoover admitted to the murder. He couldn’t offer a motive. He had no idea Mahoney was a millionaire. This created another problem. If Hoover had been in the hotel room, he would’ve noticed Mahoney’s expensive belongings and traveler’s checks.
Hoover had no recollection of his statements once the drug wore off. The authorities were torn between convenience and justice. Hoover was open to every suggestion and wanted someone else to tell him what happened. The newspapers printed what he said under the drug’s influence.
With no other resolution in sight, Hoover was indicted and arraigned for murder on March 9. The authorities emphasized that statements made under the truth serum did not constitute a confession, and they were still in search of suspects, but the media had already convicted Hoover.
His Wife
Hoover was recently married to Alberta Stroh, who was 19 years old. She first believed questioning would be the extent of Hoover’s involvement. She had been somewhere for 2 weeks, but never specified. She called it a “personal leave.” Not even the authorities were able to establish her whereabouts. When it became clear Hoover wasn’t getting out, she became vindictive. Suddenly, Hoover made her work in seedy clubs while he enjoyed an easy life, although they’d only been married a few weeks and she was absent for most of them, while he was repeatedly hospitalized.
Stroh was a Topeka native. She didn’t say Hoover was in the VA hospital in Topeka, where she met him. She also omitted the fact he’d nearly been arrested on February 18, but the officer admitted him to the New Orleans VA hospital as opposed to jail. The authorities had to discover this information independently. She said her husband was “a mental case” and they had planned to return to Topeka for further treatment. He was just released from the hospital on Monday, the eve of the crime.
She then said she was pregnant and too ill for further questioning in late February. By the time of the trial in November, she was in perfect health and without child. Hoover never had children. She surprised authorities with her enthusiasm to take the stand. They informed her she didn’t have to testify, even against an ex-husband.
She said the trip to New Orleans was their honeymoon, a stark contrast to the story she’d told police of her labor so long to financially support him. At trial, she was particularly eager to discuss her husband in “gay” places. She never had proof of her allegations. She stated that Hoover said he, “dreamed he committed the perfect crime.” Her reliability as a witness remained in question.
The Defense
Hoover’s defense attorney was Sam Monk Zelden, and occasionally his associate Max Zelden. Contrary to many murder trials, Zelden pushed for a speedy trial. There was no real evidence against Hoover. The authorities dawdled and even demanded a psychiatric evaluation. Zelden protested stating the authorities had no right to such a request, but he was overruled. Hoover was given his evaluation in July, and the doctors declared him sane.
Hoover was clearly troubled while in jail. He was taken to the scene of the murder, but only said, “I possibly may have done it, but I don’t remember.” That night, he was seized by an attack of hysteria and beat his head against the cell bars until he knocked himself out. In another fit, he used a tin cup to start cutting his wrists. The authorities overpowered him before he could inflict more than superficial wounds.
Jury selection was done under the watchful gaze of two of Mahoney’s alleged associates, although it remains unclear as to why they attended jury selection. Lum Doyle, a criminal attorney and boxing commissioner from Nebraska, was said to be some kind of distant Mahoney relative. Dick Rouse was Mahoney’s estate attorney, and also said to be a criminal attorney. The most unusual aspect of their attendance is that, despite their combined decades of experience in the courtroom, neither man made a statement, or any contribution to the case. We are left to wonder why these men were present, or if they might’ve been tied to the crime in some way.
Mahoney’s murder case made it into several detective books. Official Detective featured Bennett Wright’s article on the Mahoney case in 1949. The Real Detective Magazine carried the Mahoney story under the title Crimson Horror at the Mardi Gras. Inside Detective magazine also highlighted the case in a story called Mystery at the Mardi Gras.
Trial #1
The first trial began in November of 1949 and ran through the first day of December. It was over before it began. The authorities created a story around the details Hoover offered while on Pentothal sodium. The two men bumped into one another on the street and became friends. He dined with Mahoney, and for some reason came back to his hotel room to shower. The two lay nude on Mahoney’s bed while they talked.
According to the tale, Mahoney insulted Hoover’s wife. He beat Mahoney for the insult. He tried to shove the towel in his mouth to stop his yells, but it wouldn’t fit. So, he twisted it around his neck. He washed his hands twice, stole Mahoney’s keys, wallet, and watch. Then, he went to another hotel and registered, where he slept and didn’t wake until mid-day. The story is not without glaring flaws and improbabilities.
Emma Harrigan was the telephone operator at the Monteleone. She testified someone left a message with her between 11:21 pm and 3:00 am to wake Mahoney at 5:30 am. That is a considerable lapse of time for a murder investigation. No one questioned why she couldn’t narrow the time down any further than a four hour window.
A Royal Street Hotel Detective, Ansell Cook, claimed he briefly saw a man in a green sweater at a different hotel, although the relevance of that sighting to the case wasn’t established. A waitress named Loraine Baker testified that she saw Mahoney and Hoover dining together before the murder.
The star witness was a carnival worker named Milton “Lucky” Baker. He claimed he saw Mahoney and Hoover together. He also claimed to be an acquaintance of Hoover, and that Hoover showed him a watch and a roll of money. He claimed Hoover said he got in a fight with a man, but didn’t know if he killed him or not. Hoover couldn’t recall that night, so he made no attempt to deny what witnesses said.
John W. Hartle was the night clerk at another hotel where Hoover registered at 1:31 am, Tuesday morning. Hoover registered under his real name and had no baggage. Hoover was not covered in gore and didn’t appear to be unusually agitated. When he woke and came down later that day, he asked for directions to the VA hospital. It should be again noted that Hoover was just released from the same facility the day before.
Hoover was convicted of first-degree murder on December 2, based upon circumstantial evidence. The conviction carried an automatic death penalty. Nearly a year later, the authorities still hadn’t found Mahoney’s wallet, keys, or watch. They were not in Hoover’s possession or anywhere Hoover said they would be.
Hoover did not remain composed once the verdict was read. He wept and moaned. He was so devastated he didn’t eat the following day. He wrote Zelden from prison and stated, “as God as my witness, I did not kill James Mahoney.”
Hoover was sentenced on February 1, 1950. The judge sentenced him to be electrocuted until he was, “Dead. Dead. Dead.” Hoover again wept. Fortunately, Zelden had already submitted paperwork to the state supreme court.
Problems
The subtle lunacy of the first trial likely stemmed from desperation and the difficult Mardi Gras investigation. The Assistant District Attorney, Philip Thrice Jr., overstepped his legal boundaries during his closing arguments. He first said Hoover was a little too familiar with crime scene photographs, which proved he was familiar with the crime scene. Hoover never took the stand or handled the photographs at any time during trial. Hoover didn’t recall any contact with Mahoney whatsoever until after police questioned him.
Thrice made a number of controversial statements. The most startling was his declaration that Hoover had stayed in five mental hospitals, and made multiple suicide attempts, not because he had deep psychological issues, but just in case he needed future murder alibi. The Louisiana State Supreme Court granted the request, primarily because of Thrice’s bizarre statements, and also the lack of motive and evidence against Hoover.
Zelden changed his tactics at this point. The prosecution wanted to make it look like a robbery, but even that just wasn’t logical. He decided to tell the court that Hoover killed Mahoney because he made an “unnatural proposition.” He also brought in Dr. Hubert Winston Smith, a doctor at Tulane University, to study Hoover. After an intense interrogation, Hoover still didn’t recall anything from that evening. Hoover believed what they told him and agreed that he killed Mahoney because of inappropriate suggestions.
Hoover described a dramatic episode of violence wherein Mahoney screamed for his life. This was contrary to the fact that the occupants on either side of his room didn’t hear anything unusual. The hotel employed a number of house detectives to ensure guests were safe and to prevent theft during the celebrations. Hotel detectives regularly patrolled the floors and, despite passing Mahoney’s door several times, never heard or witnessed anything unusual.
There also wasn’t any evidence that Mahoney put up a defensive struggle or fought anyone.
Trial #2
The second trial exposed many of the dubious tactics used during the first. The “star witness” Milton Baker, was a Federal prisoner by that time and couldn’t attend. Loraine Baker, the waitress who gave damning testimony of Mahoney and Hoover together in a restaurant, was forced to elaborate. She noticed the two men at her restaurant, but they weren’t really in each other’s company. Mahoney sat in a different part of the restaurant while Hoover ate, but she said she overheard Mahoney say he waited on Hoover to finish his meal.
New Orleans Policeman Frank Marullo testified that he arrested Mahoney on February 18, 1949. The charge was not established, but Marullo told Hoover if he committed himself to the VA hospital, he wouldn’t take him to jail. Hoover did as ordered.
With the new “unnatural proposition” admission, Hoover was found guilty of second-degree murder and the death penalty was converted to life in prison. Afterward, Hoover made several alarming statements. He first said, “I am the happiest guy in the world.” He then said, “I did this because I wanted a trial. I didn’t want to spend the rest of my life in prison asking myself if Mr. Mahoney’s death was murder in the first degree. If it was, I wanted to die in the electric chair. If it wasn’t, I wanted a jury to tell me.”
Settling Up
Mahoney had a sizable estate to disperse. The court appointed two distant relatives as executors, Tom Doyle of Chicago, Illinois, and J. D. Mahoney, of Richmond, Virginia. It is believed that Lum Doyle, who attended jury selection, was a relative of Tom’s. His estate still hadn’t been settled in July of 1949. The estate was to be divided among 14 heirs.
The Mahoney estate went to auction in November of 1949. The value of the home furnishings alone was estimated to be over $20,000. One of the will’s executors didn’t want the full amount disclosed to the public, so exact total wasn’t released. The collection of interior goods included a Steinway Grand Piano. The piano was believed to have been sold to a woman from Norton, Virginia.
Today
Mahoney’s murderer was familiar with killing. The murderer was likely a man due to the sheer brutality. The killer showed no signs of panic. He knew he could clean his hands on a pair of trousers, and the authorities couldn’t use that for identification. Despite such a gory crime, the rest of the room was clean. The culprit calmly searched through Mahoney’s belongings for what he wanted afterward, and eluded witnesses on the way out.
Many glaring problems surround every detail of this case. Perhaps the largest is the startling lack of defense injuries. Mahoney was 55-years-old at the time of his death, and was in good health. He was ready to journey through the then remote and isolated Yucatan. He didn’t struggle or try to escape his attacker. This important detail implies he was either unconscious or asleep when the killer began. However, this was never addressed during the investigation.
It was also probable that Mahoney knew his killer. There were no signs of forced entry. His belongings were searched, but carefully so. The murder itself was unusually violent. Perhaps the murderer wanted to ensure he was dead, but we are left to wonder why the killer chose such a difficult and exhaustive way to murder.
We are left to guess if perhaps Mahoney had something of value to an unknown party. Whatever the killer searched for in the dead man’s belongings will never be known. It was not money, although someone made a slight attempt to disguise the murder as a robbery. Even that was ineffective because they didn’t bother to take the cameras or traveler’s checks. No one established why a thief would value anything on Mahoney’s keychain, unless there was a key for something like a safe deposit box.
The Hotel Monteleone remains in operation today. The Monteleone originally opened in the 1880s as the Commercial Hotel. The historic structure, along with the scene of this crime, was demolished in 1954. The owners constructed a modernized building, which remains a hot spot for travelers seeking luxury.
The Supreme Court eventually ruled confessions given under the influence of drugs labeled “truth serums” were inadmissible. Truth serums, usually sodium pentothal or thiopental, remain controversial. Sodium pentothal is used for anesthesia, euthanasia, medically induced comas, and it is one component of lethal injections.
Professionals established the drugs made recipients compliant and open to suggestion, which fit Hoover’s story progression as the questioning continued. First, he didn’t even recall the hotel room. Then, after further questioning, he recalled being in the hotel room. Eventually, he recalled hitting Mahoney because he insulted his wife. Finally, he remembered hitting Mahoney, stuffing a towel in his mouth, taking his watch, and disposing of the wallet.
Hoover identified Mahoney by photograph, but that didn’t prove much. When Hoover woke that Tuesday, one of the first things he did was grab a newspaper, as testified by Hoover and the hotel clerk. He could’ve seen Mahoney’s photograph in the paper. Mahoney could not have yelled, as Hoover stated, or someone would’ve heard. Had there been such a struggle, there would have been more evidence. Mardi Gras was ongoing, so people were coming and going at all hours.
This is one case where authorities changed their story as much as Hoover changed his. Mahoney’s murderer, whoever it was, did get away with a seemingly perfect crime.
Note: Sam “Monk” Zelden went on to become one of New Orleans’s most famed criminal defense attorneys. His clients included Jimmy Moran and Dean Andrews, who was involved in the JFK assassination investigation.