In January 1897, a young woman was found dead inside her home in Greenbrier County, West Virginia. Her physician initially attributed her death to heart failure, and she was buried the following day. But her mother suspected something far more sinister, and what followed would become one of the most extraordinary murder investigations in American history.
Mary Jane Heaster claimed that her daughter’s ghost returned from the grave, revealing both the identity of her murderer and the manner in which she had been killed. More remarkably, the subsequent investigation uncovered physical evidence supporting the apparition’s account.
Decades earlier, the murder case of John Gamble had helped establish a dismissive attitude toward spectral evidence in West Virginia. Yet the Greenbrier Ghost would become an unusual exception, a case in which testimony concerning a supernatural visitation entered the courtroom and became part of a murder trial.
The question was no longer simply whether a ghost had appeared. A woman had been murdered, and her mother insisted that the dead woman herself had revealed the crime.
Origins
Elva Zona Jane Heaster was born around 1873 in Greenbrier County, West Virginia, to Jacob and Mary Jane Heaster. The family was of English descent and enjoyed a comfortable living. Contrary to modern portrayals suggesting that the Heasters were impoverished, Jacob was a successful farmer, and the family also operated a boarding house.
Elva, commonly called Zona, was the eldest of several children. Little is known about her early life, but in 1896 she met a man named Erasmus Stribbling Shue, better known as “Trout.” Contemporary sources sometimes identify him as Edward, although trial records refer to him as Trout. Approximately thirty years old, Shue was born in Mossy Creek, West Virginia, to Jacob Shue, a respected blacksmith. Unlike his father, Trout had difficulty establishing himself and gained a reputation as a drifter.
Nevertheless, Zona fell in love with him. Her mother, Mary Jane, was considerably less enthusiastic. She disliked Trout almost immediately, although she could offer no particular explanation for her misgivings. Her uneasiness would eventually prove justified in a manner she could scarcely have imagined.
Marriage
Zona and Trout married in November 1896 at the Methodist Church in Livesey’s Mill. After the wedding, they moved into a two-story frame house that had formerly belonged to William G. Livesay. Their marriage initially appeared harmonious. Trout seemed attentive to his young wife, particularly when she became seriously ill in January 1897, only two months after their wedding.
Dr. Knapp, a local physician, visited the couple’s home regularly over the next two weeks. Throughout Zona’s illness, Trout appeared affectionate and devoted, tending to her needs and showing every outward sign of concern. Eventually, she seemed to recover, and there was little reason for outsiders to suspect anything was wrong. Then, on January 23, Zona was found dead.
Redrum, Sir, Is Murder
On the morning of January 23, 1897, Trout Shue left for work. Before departing, he visited an African American family living nearby and asked whether their twelve-year-old son could help Zona with some household chores.
The boy’s mother agreed, explaining that her son had chores of his own to finish first. Trout returned around eleven o’clock to ask whether the child had gone to the Shue house. He had not, but his mother assured Trout that he would visit after lunch. Trout explained that he would be working through the noon hour. Not long afterward, the boy arrived at the Shue residence and made a horrifying discovery.
Zona was dead. Her body lay on the dining room floor, her clothing pulled down and her feet positioned neatly together, almost as though someone had deliberately arranged her.
Dr. Knapp, who had recently treated Zona’s illness, was summoned to the house. Nearly an hour passed before he arrived. By then, Trout had already moved his wife’s body upstairs and begun preparing her for burial.
This was highly unusual. In the community, women customarily prepared the dead, and Trout’s interference had also disturbed the scene of an unexpected death before the authorities could examine it.
The physician encountered another difficulty. Trout refused to allow him a thorough examination of the body, crying and wailing so insistently that Knapp could accomplish little beyond a visual inspection.
The doctor nevertheless noticed something troubling. Zona appeared to have been dead considerably longer than the few hours suggested by the circumstances of her discovery. Unable to examine her properly, and mindful of her recent illness, Knapp attributed the death to heart failure.
Trout then dressed his wife for burial, choosing a garment with an unusually high collar. Around her neck, he wrapped a crepe veil like a scarf, claiming it had been her favorite. Yet no one could recall seeing Zona wear it.
Her mother placed a sheet over the body for the wake. Zona was taken to her family’s home for the funeral, but Trout’s peculiar behavior continued. Those keeping vigil noticed that he remained stationed at the head of the coffin and discouraged anyone from approaching too closely.
Another disturbing detail attracted attention. Zona’s head seemed unusually loose, moving in a manner that alarmed the mourners. When Trout noticed, he placed additional padding inside the coffin, explaining that he wished to make his wife more comfortable.
By now, the whispers had begun.
After the service, Mary Jane removed the sheet she had placed over her daughter and offered it to Trout as a keepsake. He declined, telling her to keep it.
Zona was buried on January 24, 1897. But her mother remained convinced that something was terribly wrong.
The Uncanny
Mary Jane’s suspicions only deepened after the funeral. She believed her daughter had been murdered, and before long, she claimed that Zona herself had returned to reveal the truth. According to Mary Jane, her daughter’s spirit appeared to her on four consecutive nights. During these visitations, Zona described the circumstances of her death and accused Trout of strangling her. The apparition allegedly demonstrated the injury by turning her head completely around, revealing the terrible damage that had been inflicted upon her neck.
Mary Jane also experienced another extraordinary occurrence involving the sheet she had removed from Zona’s coffin. When she attempted to wash it, both the fabric and the washwater reportedly turned a brilliant blood red. No other clothing or material was affected, only the sheet that had covered her daughter’s body.
For Mary, the incident removed any lingering doubt. She was convinced that Zona had returned from the grave, and she intended to see that her daughter’s murderer was brought to justice.
Formalities
Mary Jane Heaster visited the local prosecutor and spent several hours recounting the circumstances surrounding Zona’s death and her alleged supernatural visitations. Whether the prosecutor believed her account of the apparition is uncertain. He was, however, aware of the growing suspicion surrounding Trout Shue’s conduct, and Mary’s visit prompted him to take a closer look at the case.
Witnesses were questioned again, including Dr. Knapp, who admitted that Trout had prevented him from conducting a proper examination of Zona’s body. Combined with the accounts of Shue’s behavior before and during the funeral, the testimony provided sufficient grounds to authorize an exhumation.
Trout strongly objected. He protested both the removal of the body and the subsequent inquest, even demanding permission to attend the autopsy. Authorities refused. Constable Jim Shawver assembled an inquest jury of six, and Zona’s remains were removed from Soul Chapel Cemetery. The examination took place at the nearby Nickels schoolhouse, with Justice Homer McClung presiding over the proceedings.
Among the jurors was W. H. Squire Burns. State Attorney John A. Preston led the prosecution, assisted by Henry Gilmer. The autopsy was conducted by Drs. Rupert, Knapp, and Machesney. Initially, they found no evidence of poisoning or significant damage to Zona’s internal organs. But Burns noticed something peculiar about the condition of her head, which seemed unusually loose even for a body that had been buried for approximately a month.
The physicians turned their attention to her neck. What they discovered was extraordinary.
Zona’s windpipe had been crushed, and finger marks were visible around her throat. The injuries, concealed by the clothing Trout had selected for her burial, provided unmistakable evidence of strangulation. The findings corresponded with the description Mary Jane claimed to have received from her daughter’s ghost.
On March 4, local newspapers announced, “Foul Play Suspected.” Soon afterward, Henry Gilmer arrested Trout Shue and placed him in the Lewisburg jail. Trout appeared remarkably unconcerned. He reportedly acknowledged that he had expected to be arrested but remained confident the authorities would never prove his guilt.
The elaborate displays of grief that had accompanied Zona’s death were conspicuously absent. More suspicious information came out during the investigation. Shue had returned at lunch to ensure the boy had gone to help Zona. He hadn’t. The family lived next door to the Shue home. Had it been his actual motive, he could’ve just checked on his wife, himself, instead of asking the neighbor.
As investigators examined Trout’s past, they discovered that Zona had not been his first wife. Depending on the account, she was his third or fourth. At approximately thirty years of age, Shue had already experienced several marriages.
His first wife had divorced him on grounds of extreme cruelty, while later wives had reportedly either disappeared or died under suspicious circumstances. The revelations did little to improve his standing.
The Trial
Judge J. M. McWhorter presided over Trout Shue’s trial. The defense was represented by William Rucker and James Gardener, identified as the first African American attorney in Greenbrier County and the first in West Virginia to defend a white man. Some sources identify Gardener as Jas. P. D. Graham.
The defense attempted to undermine Mary Jane Heaster’s testimony, questioning the reliability of her account and the extraordinary circumstances surrounding her daughter’s alleged appearances. Mary, however, remained unwavering.
When Trout took the stand, his own testimony was marked by contradictions, further damaging his credibility. The proceedings also revealed that he had previously served a prison sentence for horse theft.
Mary Jane even brought the sheet associated with her daughter’s funeral into the courtroom, presenting the object she claimed had mysteriously turned blood red.
The twelve jurors were B. Gardner, D. S. Lockhart, B. Stuart, Charles W. Dunbar, W. Hogsett, J. M. Hughart, T. W. McClung, J. A. Vaughan, M. Thomasson, J. A. Hartsock, J. R. Ridgeway, and Richard Blofield. Ultimately, the evidence proved overwhelming. Trout Shue was convicted of murdering his wife.
The Greenbrier Ghost case became one of the most unusual episodes in American legal history, not because a court formally established the existence of ghosts, but because a mother’s account of her daughter’s supernatural return, and the startlingly accurate details it gave, became part of the testimony surrounding a murder conviction. What began as an apparently natural death had become a homicide investigation, and the injuries discovered during the autopsy corresponded with the extraordinary story Mary Jane had told.
The Sentence
Trout Shue’s trial lasted eight days, but the jury required only an hour to reach its verdict. On July 11, he was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to life imprisonment at the West Virginia State Penitentiary in Moundsville.
His conviction did not satisfy everyone. A mob led by John Seward assembled with the intention of lynching Shue. George Harrah learned of the plan and alerted Sheriff Nickel, who persuaded the crowd to disperse, reminding them that justice had already been delivered through the courts.
Nevertheless, the authorities remained concerned that the mob might return. As a precaution, Shue was handcuffed to Deputy John Dwyer, and the prisoner, deputy, and sheriff concealed themselves in a cornfield overnight. The following morning, Trout was hurried away to the penitentiary, beyond the immediate reach of vigilante justice. Even imprisonment apparently failed to diminish his arrogance. Despite receiving a life sentence, Shue continued boasting that he intended to marry seven women before his death.
He never had the opportunity. Trout Shue died approximately eight years into his sentence. Many accounts attribute his death to an unidentified epidemic within the prison, although rumors persisted that he had been murdered. The exact circumstances remain uncertain.
For Mary Jane Heaster, however, the question of her daughter’s death had finally been answered. The man she believed responsible had been convicted, and the injuries discovered in Zona’s grave had confirmed the terrible violence described in her account of the apparition. Whether Zona truly returned from the dead remains another matter entirely.
What is certain is that a mother’s insistence upon the truth led to the reopening of a death investigation, the discovery of a murder, and the conviction of the man responsible. The Greenbrier Ghost had apparently accomplished what the living could not.
A Child?
One persistent element of the Greenbrier Ghost story concerns the suggestion that Zona Heaster had given birth to a child outside marriage. The claim appears in various retellings, but I have found no convincing historical evidence to support it.
Had Zona entered her marriage with an illegitimate child, the circumstances would likely have attracted considerable attention, particularly given the social attitudes of the period. It is also reasonable to suspect that Trout’s attorneys might have used such information during his trial if they believed it could benefit their client’s defense. Yet the surviving accounts examined for this article contain no substantial discussion of such a child.
There is another difficulty with the story. Evidence suggests Zona had been dead for more than twelve hours when her body was discovered. Had a young child been present in the household, its cries or other needs might have attracted attention long before the neighbor’s son arrived.
Neither argument conclusively establishes that Zona had a child. Nevertheless, the absence of supporting testimony or documentation makes the claim doubtful. Until credible historical evidence emerges, the alleged child is best regarded as an unsubstantiated addition to an already extraordinary story.