Laura Wright 
Urban Legends
Every city has a house teenagers dare one another to visit.
Usually it stands somewhere out of the way.
The windows are broken.
The yard is overgrown.
Nobody seems to live there.
And everybody knows what happened inside.
At least, everybody thinks they do.
For generations of young people in San Antonio, Texas, one such place was known as the Midget Mansion.
The stories surrounding it were gruesome.
An entire family had supposedly been murdered inside.
Some versions claimed the victims had been sealed inside a room.
Others said they had been walled up alive.
Still others insisted the people who lived there were cannibals.
There was only one problem.
Nobody could find evidence that any of it happened.
The Mansion
According to the legend, the house was constructed sometime after the Civil War.
A retired Navy captain and his wife supposedly built the residence but remained there only briefly.
Eventually, they sold it to another family.
And this was where the legend became strange.
The new owners were supposedly little people.
The husband was remembered by the name Gillespie. He became a successful businessman during the 1920s, and the family reportedly included his wife, two daughters of average height and several servants.
The architecture supposedly reflected the owners’ stature.
Ceilings were unusually low.
Fixtures hung closer to the floor.
Parts of the house appeared smaller than visitors expected.
Eventually, people began imagining an entire mansion constructed specifically for people of short stature.
Then something terrible supposedly happened there.
Gillespie Goes Mad
According to the best-known version of the story, Gillespie suffered harassment because of his height despite his success in business.
Eventually, something inside him broke.
One night, he murdered his family.
He slit their throats.
Then he dragged the bodies into a spare room and sealed them inside.
After murdering everyone else in the house, Gillespie took a handgun and killed himself.
The prosperous family disappeared.
The mansion became a murder house.
And nobody wanted it anymore.
At least, that is how the story was told.
The Abandoned House
Years passed.
The property deteriorated.
Eventually, the old mansion became exactly the sort of place guaranteed to attract teenagers.
It was abandoned.
Overgrown.
Decaying.
And supposedly haunted by an entire murdered family.
Young people broke into the property.
Vandals damaged it.
Others simply wanted to see the infamous rooms for themselves.
And every person who visited potentially carried another version of the story back home.
That is how urban legends thrive.
One teenager hears something upstairs.
Another sees a shadow.
Someone notices an unusually low ceiling.
By Monday morning, everybody at school knows why.
The Family Behind the Wall
As the legend circulated, it became increasingly gruesome.
In one variation, Gillespie didn’t merely murder his family and hide their bodies.
Some of them were supposedly still alive when he sealed them inside the room.
Trapped behind the wall, the dying victims left messages describing what had happened.
Sometimes those messages were supposedly scratched into the wall.
In particularly grisly versions, they were written in blood.
That would certainly make the story memorable.
Unfortunately, there is no evidence it happened.
The Shotgun Version
Other storytellers changed the murder weapon.
Gillespie didn’t slit anyone’s throat.
He used a shotgun.
He murdered the entire household and then turned the weapon upon himself.
The basic structure remained unchanged.
Wealthy family.
Unusual mansion.
Mass murder.
Suicide.
Abandoned house.
Ghosts.
Only the details moved around.
And then the legend became considerably stranger.
The Cannibals
One version claimed that the little people who occupied the mansion were cannibals.
That transformed the supposed victims of the original story into monsters themselves.
Another version reversed the roles completely.
The owners weren’t little people at all.
The servants were.
And rather than Gillespie murdering his household, the servants murdered the family for their money.
Afterward, the killers argued over how the stolen fortune should be divided.
The disagreement became violent.
Eventually, they killed one another.
By this point, almost every component of the story could change while the Midget Mansion itself remained constant.
That is one of the clearest signs that we’re dealing with folklore rather than a remembered historical crime.
The Truth About Midget Mansion
There really was an unusual old property associated with the legend.
Your original identifies it as Donore Manor, although the spelling also appears in retellings in varying forms.
Several San Antonio properties have apparently been called the Midget Mansion over the years, making identification even more difficult.
But there is no known historical record supporting the central legend.
No Gillespie family massacre.
No murder-suicide.
No family discovered behind a wall.
No cannibal household.
No murderous servants fighting over stolen money.
And, most importantly, no formal evidence that a family of little people ever occupied the house at all.
The monster wasn’t inside the mansion.
It was in the story people told about it.
Why Was Everything So Small?
The architecture probably helped create the legend.
The old house reportedly had unusually low ceilings and low-hanging fixtures.
To teenagers exploring an abandoned mansion, the explanation must have seemed obvious.
Short people lived there.
But low ceilings aren’t particularly mysterious in older buildings.
Before central heating, large rooms with extremely high ceilings could be difficult and expensive to keep warm. Smaller spaces were considerably more practical.
There was another possible explanation as well.
The original owner himself was reportedly rather short.
According to the account preserved in the article, he stood approximately five feet tall.
He wasn’t a mysterious millionaire from a family of little people.
He was simply a short man.
That may have been enough.
An Urban Legend Is Born
The really revealing date is the 1970s.
According to your original research, the Midget Mansion legend isn’t known to exist before then.
That’s enormously important.
If Gillespie really murdered an entire household during the 1920s, there should have been something to find.
Newspaper coverage.
Death records.
Police involvement.
Funerals.
Property records.
A sensational multiple homicide involving a wealthy businessman and his entire family would not ordinarily disappear completely from local history only to reemerge half a century later as teenage folklore.
Instead, the story seems to have appeared after the house had already become old, neglected and mysterious.
That suggests a much simpler sequence.
First came the house.
Then came the legend.
The House Falls Into Ruin
The descendants of the original family reportedly left the property during the 1960s.
Without regular occupation and maintenance, the old residence deteriorated.
And an abandoned house is practically a factory for folklore.
Windows break.
Floors sag.
Animals get inside.
Wind moves through damaged walls.
Plumbing groans.
Teenagers trespass.
Someone tells a frightening story.
Then somebody else improves it.
Within a generation, an ordinary abandoned house can acquire a massacre.
Why the Story Worked
Midget Mansion contains nearly every ingredient of a successful urban legend.
There is a real location.
The building is unusual.
Nobody seems to know exactly what happened there.
The story contains murder.
There is a sealed room.
The victims supposedly leave a final message.
The murderer kills himself.
And the house is abandoned afterward.
Best of all, teenagers can actually visit it.
That last ingredient is important.
This isn’t merely a story someone tells around a campfire.
It’s a story followed by:
“I know where the house is.”
Suddenly everyone wants to go.
The Mansion Disappears
Eventually, the old property was demolished.
Development replaced it.
The physical object that generated the legend disappeared.
That should have killed the story.
Instead, it may have helped preserve it.
Once a legendary building is gone, inconvenient evidence disappears with it.
Nobody can walk through the house and discover that the mysterious miniature staircase isn’t actually there.
Nobody can ask the occupants who lived in which room.
Nobody can photograph the architecture and compare it with the stories.
The mansion becomes whatever people remember it being.
And memory is remarkably generous to a good ghost story.
The Midget Mansion
No evidence suggests that an entire family was murdered inside the legendary San Antonio mansion.
There is no documented Gillespie massacre.
No sealed room containing bodies.
No bloody message from dying victims.
No murderous household of cannibals.
No servants slaughtering one another over stolen money.
But that doesn’t make the Midget Mansion uninteresting.
It makes it a nearly perfect example of an urban legend developing around a real place.
There was an unusual old house.
Its proportions caught people’s attention.
The property became abandoned.
Teenagers began exploring it.
Someone supplied an explanation.
Then somebody made the explanation frightening.
Another person made it bloodier.
Another added ghosts.
Another added cannibals.
By the time the story had finished growing, an old San Antonio residence had become the site of a massacre that apparently never happened.
Perhaps that’s the real lesson of Midget Mansion.
A haunted house doesn’t always need a murder.
Sometimes it doesn’t even need a ghost.
It needs an abandoned building, a few unusual architectural features and generations of teenagers willing to say:
“My friend’s older brother went inside, and he swears this really happened.”
That will do nicely.
About the Author
